Main Menu
· Home
· Issues
· Articles
· Advice
· Q&A
· Audio Bayaans
· Books
· Downloads
· Al-Haq
· Search
· Subscribe
· Recommend Us


Issues

Q&A Search


Newsletter
You are currently not logged in, but you can still subscribe to our newsletter.




Upcoming Books
book cover
Irshaadul Mulook

TheMajlis.net Questions and Answers Page


Category: Main ->


Question
  • Modernists are lately making much negative propaganda regarding the prohibition of women attending Musjids. Please explain the Shariah’s view on this issue.

  • A son works in his father’ shop. Although his father sees to the expenses of the son’s home and family, he does no pay him a fixed wage. Will the son be within his rights to ask his father to pay him a wage?

  • Is it permissible for Muslim women to wear pants made of denim fabric?

  • A Maulana said that during Muharram, the Masnoon fasting is only one day, on the 10th. Fasting two days is not Sunnat.

  • It is said that during Fardh Salaat, one should not skip one Surah among the short Surahs. If a short Surah is recited in the first raka’t, the next short Surah thereafter should be recited in the second raka’t. If not, then at least two Surahs should be skipped. Which are the short Surahs referred to?

  • I started Zuhr Salaat very late. After having made one raka’t, Asr time commenced. What is the position of my Zuhr Salaat which I completed during Asr time?

  • Is it permissible to buy and consume any food items which are related to non-Muslim religious customs, e.g. hotcross buns, easter eggs, etc.

  • Is the use of condoms permissible?

  • A casino has opened up in Durban. Most of the exhibitions, car shows, graduation ceremonies, etc., which used to take place at other venues, now take place within the casino complex. As a result, many Muslims who used to frequent these shows when they were held elsewhere, are now entering the casino complex to participate and attend the accompanying attractions. Please comment.

  • Jalsahs and public programmes of the Deobandi Maulanas in our time are increasingly assuming the form and style of the jalsahs and programmes of the Bareilli group. Naats, nazams, group thikr, feasting and the like are common to the gatherings of both groups. The only difference is that the Bareillis have their compulsory meelaad accompanying every function. What is happening to the Ulama of Deoband?

  • Many Muslims have male servants in their homes. Is it necessary for the women in the home to observe purdah for male servants keeping in mind the need to be always in communication with them?

  • Some people use dead chickens as bait to catch fish. What is the Shariah’s ruling? And what about selling such bait?

  • Is cell phone ‘music’ permissible?

  • Medical fees are exorbitant and the costs for major surgery or private hospital treatment is beyond the financial means of most people. The position of state hospitals is deplorable. In these circumstances is it permissible to take out a medical scheme?

  • I suffer from an ailment on my finger. The only treatment which helps is a kind of a liquid which is waterproof. If this is not applied, the ailment spreads to the other fingers as well. What is the position of my wudhu and ghusl?

  • A new method of contraception is on the market. A patch of plaster is put on one’s arm. It has to be changed once a week, and it gives the same results as contraceptive pills. Is it permissible to use this new method?

  • Commenting on the recent alcohol content of Coke, SANHA in a statement says: “Coke bottling plants however, exclusively bottle Coke products and do not bottle any alcoholic beverages. This was confirmed by our personal visit to a Coke-Bottling Plant.” Sanha also assured that “Coke do not add any liquor in the manufacture of Coke products”. What does The Majlis say on this issue?

  • Is it permissible for women to wear imitation jewellery?

  • Can any other Tasbeeh besides the usual Tasbeeh be recited in Ruku and Sajdah?

  • A man said to his wife: “If you cut your hair, you are divorced.” If the wife does not cut her hair herself but asks someone else to cut it, will the ruling differ?

  • When someone dies in our family, members of the family congregate at the home of the deceased. A lady from the community is contracted to prepare the food for us. The food is not simple. Exotic Italian food, pasta, steak, salad, chicken, etc., etc. are the dishes. It is like Eid. Cakes and refreshments are also served. The mourners and sympathisers all join in the feast. This feasting continues for a couple of days, up to the 1st weekend. What is the view of the Shariah on this type of feasting?

  • I am a layman and in need of guidance. A Maulana visits our town twice every year since the past 7 years. Over the past five years the Maulana conducted khaanqah, and also I’tikaaf of the last ten days of Ramadhaan. Programmes are tight throughout. The ladies programmes are held daily for two hours. Though we do have a radio transmitter at the Mosque and most houses have radios, the visiting Maulana does not allow switching on these transmitters. He insists that the women should travel to the Mosque where they sit in the hall and listen. These ladies travel about 10 km alone or with a driver. Is it proper to allow these ladies to travel these distances to listen to the bayaan of the Maulana?

  • Q. Is the 10 day Ramadhaan I’tikaaf an infiraadi (individual) or an Ijtima-i (congregational) ibaadat? Most of the people need a break because the daily schedules are tight and extensive. Feeding roughly 100 people daily for 10 days —Sehri, Iftaar, Dinner after Taraaweeh and again after the night bayaan at about 11 pm. The Maulana’s host and his mureeds are compelled to participate in this khaanqah activity every year. The participants have a hypocritical stand. The majority talks negatively of this state of affairs. Please comment.

  • According to Hadhrat Mufti Shafi (rahmatullah alayh), burning incense in the Musjid is a Sunnat practice which should be revived, yet The Majlis has labelled it a bid’ah. Please comment on this conflict.

  • If one owns more than one property which are utilized to generate income, are the values of these properties subject to Zakaat?

  • A Maulana has been employed to be the Imaam of a Musjid. After one and half years he suddenly started holding the Asaa during the Jumuah khutbah.

  • Some time ago I gave my business to my son to escape the heavy burden of debts. However, I still use funds from the business to finance some of my other projects. I intend to go for Nafl Hajj, but I was advised to rather pay the debts instead of going for Nafl Hajj. I wish to go for Hajj as I feel that I am not responsible for the debts as my son is now the owner of the business. Also, the debts are business debts not personal debts. Please advise.

  • There is a piece of land opposite the Musjid. This land was on sale for more than a year. Everyone in the community was aware of this. About a month ago a Muslim of this locality purchased the land. Some members of the Musjid committee objected to him purchasing the land. They claim that from the beginning the Musjid committee was interested in this land. The committee had approached the owner of the land on numerous occasions, but due to the high price did not buy it. According to the committee the Musjid had the first right of purchase. Secondly, they claim that the purchaser was dutibound to first inform the Musjid committee of his intention to buy the land. Although the purchaser did send someone to inform the Musjid committee of his intention to buy, they did not respond at that time. Many Muslims were interested in buying the land, but the Musjid committee prevented them. • Was it permissible for the Musjid committee to prevent others from purchasing the land? • Is it correct that the Musjid has the first right of buying the land? • Was it binding on the purchaser to inform the Musjid committee of his intention to purchase the land? • Does the Musjid committee have any right of objecting to the sale?

  • I request that The Majlis research and publish its findings on the computer games in which the youth indulge in today. The evil, satanic and immoral sexual content is extremely explicit.

  • If a wife works and earns, does it still remain the obligation of the husband to see to her nafqah (household expenses)?

  • Have you approved the financial schemes of Westbank? Some Ulama say that the Mujlisul Ulama has sanctioned it.

  • A husband said to his wife in anger: “We are already half divorced.” Is this a valid Talaaq?

  • In most Musjids around Dewsbury, England, the Committees are charging membership fees, as if to say that the Musjid is some kind of club. Is this permissible?

  • Is copyright permissible in Islam? If not, why?

  • I have heard some people saying that if a plant such as a rose plant is put on the grave, the athaab of Allah does not come. Also, if some berries are planted and the birds come and eat, they recite Tasbeeh for the mayyit. Is this correct?

  • Are all Shiah sects non-Muslim due to their outrageous beliefs?

  • I have been told that the Salafis reject the four Math-habs. Is this true?

  • In a Musjid a musalli going out, passes about 3 metres in front of someone performing Salaat. Does his Salaat break?

  • A young Maulana from Jalalabad propagates that it is not Sunnat to engage in the congregational dua after Fardh Salaat. His attitude has eroded the significance of this dua, hence many musallis who used to participate in the Ijtimaa’i Dua no longer do so. What is the status of this Dua after Fardh Salaat?

  • I read in an Islamic newsletter that the wall of Dhul-Qarnayn is located in a place called Durbend in the former Soviet Union. Is this true?

  • I bought some clothes and received 10% discount. However, I returned the clothes for a refund. There was no defect in the goods. I was given a refund of the actual price. I told them to deduct the 10% which they had given me, but they insisted on giving me the full price. In other words, I made a 10% profit. Is it proper for me to accept and use this money?

  • Is it permissible to perform Salaat with Tayammum on a plane?

  • Please explain the difference between TV and Computer pictures.

  • I have an uncle who works for an insurance company. If he invites us or gives us food as a gift, is it permissible to eat his food and accept his gifts?

  • Is it permissible to consume processed food manufactured in Islamic countries if the products contain doubtful additives?

  • How should a carpet soiled with urine be purified?

  • While travelling in a car, during an argument with my wife, I lost my temper and uttered: “Talaaq, Talaaq, Talaaq, and again Talaaq, Talaaq, Talaaq.” What is our marital status? A sheikh from an Islamic institute says that Talaaq did not take place.

  • Are nazams with thikr in the background permissible?

  • Are Raatibul Gadat gatherings permissible? They get together reciting various Surahs aloud in chorus.

  • Please state the Shariah’s ruling on ‘big walk’ functions conducted for charity and other purposes. Thousands of Muslims gather to participate in a 10 km walk for charity. Sheikhs and Imaams, men, women and children all participate. Does Islam allow this kind of behaviour?

  • Is it permissible to buy and sell cell phones with built-in cameras?

  • I have been told that Ishraaq and Dhuhaa (Chaasht) are one and the same Salaat. Is this correct?

  • How is it to join the Asr Jamaat which Shaafis perform during a time which is still Zuhr for Hanafis?

  • What is the Sunnat method of applying oil to the hair and beard?

  • There is a Muslim club called Crescent Running Club. Among its activities are mixing of sexes. Wives mix with men who are not their husbands, yet some of them perform their Namaaz. Is there any scope in Islam for such a club?

  • What are the Shariah’s requirements regarding the funeral rites for a stillborn child?

  • Is it permissible to erect four walls around the grave without plastering over the grave?

  • Is it Sunnat to make dua after walking 70 steps from the grave, after having buried the mayyit?

  • The mother of a deceased child is a Muslim and the father a non-Muslim. How should the child be buried—as a Muslim or non-Muslim?

  • When the muath-thin is absent, and present in the Musjid are only the Imaam and one musalli who is beardless, wears his trousers below his ankles, does not wear a topi and has renounced the Hanafi Mathhab which he used to follow, who should recite the Athaan and the Iqaamah?

  • Is it permissible to invest in the Unit Trust schemes which Muslim banks offer?

  • I asked a friend to pay my Zakaat. He did so with his own money. After he paid my Zakaat, I forwarded the money to him. Is my Zakaat validly discharged?

  • Is it permissible to buy and deal in shares on the stock exchange?

  • Is it permissible to participate in the Oasis Crescent Equity Fund and in Al-Baraka Equity Fund?

  • Is bovine gelatine halaal?

  • Is it permissible for a Muslim to sponsor a golf tournament?

  • Last year during the Taraaweeh Salaat announcements were made in our Musaajid regarding Sajdah Tilaawat in the 23rd Juz. Since the Sajdah at this juncture is a Sajdah Shukr for Shaafis, they were advised to remain standing while Hanafis make the Sajdah which is Waajib for them. Please comment on this issue.

  • Why is it that most Muslim businessmen pay their staff very poorly? They would rather donate large amounts to Tsunami victims, Bangladesh, Palestine, Iraq, Khanqas, etc. But they seem to think that paying their staff properly is not meritorious. Their wives get the best of everything while we cannot afford to buy a good set of clothes for our wives. They go out in jamaat, Hajj and Umrah, and they waste so much money on their children. They buy cars for their children. Please comment on this attitude of the businessmen.

  • A woman wanted to cut her hair. Her husband said: ‘If you cut your hair, you are divorced.’ What if she, herself, does not cut her hair, but asks someone else to cut it? Will Talaaq come into effect?


    Answer
    ·  Modernists are lately making much negative propaganda regarding the prohibition of women attending Musjids. Please explain the Shariah’s view on this issue.

    In the past we have explained this question in detail. Our book, `Women in Musaajid’ [also available online at http://books.themajlis.net/node/369], is available from the Y.M.M.A, P. O. Box 18594, Actonville 1506. As for those modernists who are stupidly propagating the idea of permissibility for women to attend the Musjid, it appears that they suffer some hormonial derangement, hence they, like Qadhafi, the khuntha, always desire to be in female company. Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) had ordered the expulsion from Madinah Munawwarah of such physically and mentally deranged and defective people who are known as hermaphrodites, and khuntha mushkiel in the Shariah.

    All Muslims are aware of the Shariah’s view on this issue. Everyone is aware that from time immemorial—from the very age of the Sahaabah—women were required to perform Salaat in their homes, not in the Musaajid. All over the world, among all Muslim nations, be they black, white, brown, yellow or of any other hue, the practice always was and still is, for women to perform Salaat in their homes. The recent practices of women gatecrashing into the Musaajid and the trend to demarcate secluded areas in the Musjid for females, are the ways of deviates. One simple, unambiguous Hadith of Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) will suffice to clinch this argument. Nabi-e-Kareem (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) said: “The best Salaat of a woman is her Salaat in the remotest corner of her home.” Nothing abrogates this clear directive of Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam). The plethora of nonsensical arguments and drivel which deviates and murtadds present in the attempt to negate the Shariah’s prohibition, is devoid of substance.

    Back to top


    ·  A son works in his father’ shop. Although his father sees to the expenses of the son’s home and family, he does no pay him a fixed wage. Will the son be within his rights to ask his father to pay him a wage?

    It is not permissible for the son to demand wages from his father. A wage contract between father and son is not valid in the Shariah because it is Waajib on the son to render service to his father.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible for Muslim women to wear pants made of denim fabric?

    It is not permissible for even Muslim males to wear such pants.

    Back to top


    ·  A Maulana said that during Muharram, the Masnoon fasting is only one day, on the 10th. Fasting two days is not Sunnat.

    The Maulana Saheb has erred. One should fast on two days, either 9th and 10th or 10th and 11th.

    Back to top


    ·  It is said that during Fardh Salaat, one should not skip one Surah among the short Surahs. If a short Surah is recited in the first raka’t, the next short Surah thereafter should be recited in the second raka’t. If not, then at least two Surahs should be skipped. Which are the short Surahs referred to?

    The short Surahs are from Surah Zilzaal until Surah Naas.

    Back to top


    ·  I started Zuhr Salaat very late. After having made one raka’t, Asr time commenced. What is the position of my Zuhr Salaat which I completed during Asr time?

    The Salaat is valid. However, if this delay was due to carelessness, then you had sinned.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to buy and consume any food items which are related to non-Muslim religious customs, e.g. hotcross buns, easter eggs, etc.

    It is not permissible to buy, sell or consume such items. These food items are prepared on specific religious occasions and they have religious significance. Allah Ta’ala has provided Muslims with thousands of halaal and non-Mushtabah food items. It is most despicable for the Muslim’s heart to incline to spiritually contaminated foodstuff.

    Back to top


    ·  Is the use of condoms permissible?

    Minds polluted with the immorality of the western cult of life dwell on such immoral items. It should be understood that the primary motive underlying the production and distribution of these items of shaitaan, is ‘safe’ zina (fornication). Fornication has spread like wildfire in the wake of these filthy instruments of zina. It is haraam for Muslims to use such vile instruments of zina. Besides the evil spiritual effect, these despicable items cause physical injury as well.

    Back to top


    ·  A casino has opened up in Durban. Most of the exhibitions, car shows, graduation ceremonies, etc., which used to take place at other venues, now take place within the casino complex. As a result, many Muslims who used to frequent these shows when they were held elsewhere, are now entering the casino complex to participate and attend the accompanying attractions. Please comment.

    Muslims of healthy Imaan will understand the evil and prohibition without even being told. Casinos are places of immorality on which the Wrath and Curse of Allah Ta’ala descend. Those who frequent such immoral places are under Allah’s Wrath. Even though the physical punishment may not always be descending, spiritual punishment and misfortunes perpetually settle on the participants.

    Back to top


    ·  Jalsahs and public programmes of the Deobandi Maulanas in our time are increasingly assuming the form and style of the jalsahs and programmes of the Bareilli group. Naats, nazams, group thikr, feasting and the like are common to the gatherings of both groups. The only difference is that the Bareillis have their compulsory meelaad accompanying every function. What is happening to the Ulama of Deoband?

    Normal decadence is setting in. The further one journeys from the source of light, the darker it becomes. Regrettably, the same fate which overtook the Bareilis, is now gradually being adopted by even our Ulama. The liberalism, bid’ah and haraam activities of the Ahl-e-Bid’ah and the modernists are settling over our learned men, our Madaaris and khaanqahs. The Janaazah of Haqq is in the process of being carted away from our Institutions which were at one time the bastions of Haqq and the Beacons of Divine Light. The very same fate which has destroyed and obliterated Jamiah Azhar of Cairo and other great Islamic institutions of learning in Arabia and Central Asia, is now gripping almost all our Deeni institutions, not only here in South Africa, but in India and Pakistan as well. The Uloom of the Deen is no longer being imparted nor pursued for the sake of Allah Ta’ala and the Aakhirah. It is being pursued for mercenary and nafsaani motives, hence today Tasawwuf means halqah thikr, khatm-e-khaajgaan, jalsahs, singing songs (nazams) and poetry. And, knowledge at the Madaaris is being pursued for name, fame, and earning a livelihood. Qiyaamah cannot be too far away.

    Back to top


    ·  Many Muslims have male servants in their homes. Is it necessary for the women in the home to observe purdah for male servants keeping in mind the need to be always in communication with them?

    Purdah is Waajib. The constant ‘communication’ is an aggravating factor and makes purdah more stringent. In fact, it is not permissible to have male servants inside the home. It should also be remembered that it is Waajib for the males to observe strict purdah for the female servants in the home. Most people are extremely careless in this respect. Many, many cases of moral turpitude occur in this domain.

    Back to top


    ·  Some people use dead chickens as bait to catch fish. What is the Shariah’s ruling? And what about selling such bait?

    Dead chickens are carrion. It is not permissible to feed carrion to even dogs. It is not permissible to use carrion as bait to catch fish. Selling carrion is haraam. The money acquired from such sales is haraam.

    Back to top


    ·  Is cell phone ‘music’ permissible?

    It is just as haraam as all other music.

    Back to top


    ·  Medical fees are exorbitant and the costs for major surgery or private hospital treatment is beyond the financial means of most people. The position of state hospitals is deplorable. In these circumstances is it permissible to take out a medical scheme?

    All medical schemes in vogue are ribaqimaar contracts, hence not permissible. Furthermore, most medical schemes taken out on a voluntary basis are the preserve of the wealthy. The premium payments are beyond the means of most people. Muslims should not cast their gaze to haraam ways and means. We are supposed to repose our trust on Allah Ta’ala. He suffices for us. When sickness overtakes us, Allah Ta’ala will make some arrangement. The Qur’aan Majeed says: "He who fears Allah (adopts taqwa), He (Allah) opens up an avenue for him, and He feeds him from such a source which he never even imagined of." — (Qur’aan)

    Regarding the compulsory form of medical aid in which employers make deductions from wages without the workers having any option, the benefits of this scheme may be acquired. In a compulsory scheme, there is no valid contract, hence no riba. The worker may, therefore, accept the benefit of the medical aid as a gift. But it is not permissible to enter into these schemes voluntarily.

    Back to top


    ·  I suffer from an ailment on my finger. The only treatment which helps is a kind of a liquid which is waterproof. If this is not applied, the ailment spreads to the other fingers as well. What is the position of my wudhu and ghusl?

    Both wudhu and ghusl are valid. This is similar to a bandage or plaster. Masah on the bandage/plaster suffices. Since water is passed over the impervious layer which the liquid forms, it is an adequate substitute for masah. Your ghusl and wudhu are valid as long as the ailment is not cured.

    Back to top


    ·  A new method of contraception is on the market. A patch of plaster is put on one’s arm. It has to be changed once a week, and it gives the same results as contraceptive pills. Is it permissible to use this new method?

    All forms of contraception hitherto existing and all forms which will still be invented, are unnatural ways and means. All methods which suppress and interfere with the natural bodily functions created by Allah Ta’ala are most assuredly harmful and injurious to the body. This applies to even the tablets which some women take to suppress their monthly haidh (menses) cycle. The effect of these tablets is the creation of complications, sickness, displacement of the normal cycle and the unpredictability of the cycles. Confusion between haidh and istihaadhah is also among the effects of the unnatural tablets which compels the absorption and assimilation of filth and impurities by the body. At one time the contraceptive pill as well as other methods of contraception were marketed as ‘safe’ measures. But later, the western medical establishment itself confirmed the great harms of these unnatural methods invented to fight the Taqdeer of Allah Ta’ala. We are not aware of this new plaster method.

    However, despite its overt ‘safety’, we are almost certain that time will expose the harms of even this method. Nevertheless, if there is a real, valid, pressing need to use it, for example, the ill-health of the woman, it will be permissible. But, do remember: no one can thwart the decree of Allah Azza Wa Jal. The soul whom He has decreed to appear on earth, shall do so regardless of whatever contraception is used.

    Back to top


    ·  Commenting on the recent alcohol content of Coke, SANHA in a statement says: “Coke bottling plants however, exclusively bottle Coke products and do not bottle any alcoholic beverages. This was confirmed by our personal visit to a Coke-Bottling Plant.” Sanha also assured that “Coke do not add any liquor in the manufacture of Coke products”. What does The Majlis say on this issue?

    The Majlis had spoken on this issue about 25 years ago and thereafter, again, on several occasions. We have also published a booklet explaining the alcohol-content of almost all soft drinks, not only Coke. Sanha speaks drivel. These incompetent men are not rendering any service to the Deen with their accursed ‘halaal’ certification. On the contrary, they are a disaster for the Imaan and Akhlaaq of Muslims. The statement of Sanha clearly displays a brief and a bias for Coke. In fact, Sanha is acting as a spokesman for Coke Bottling Plant.

    When Coke says that they do not add ‘liquor’ or ‘alcohol’ to their soft drinks during the process of manufacture, they have in mind the meaning of ‘liquor’ in their culture. Thus, to them ‘liquor’ is what is sold in the bottle stores—the wines which people purchase to get drunk—whisky, sherry, vodka, gin and all the other rot which derange the minds of men. But in the Shariah every intoxicating liquid is liquor/alcohol regardless of the small quantity. Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) said: “Every intoxicant is haraam.” “Whatever in great quantity intoxicates, a little quantity too
    is haraam.”


    Sanha’s defence of the Coke Bottling Plant does not negate the alcohol-content of its soft drinks notwithstanding the claim that ‘liquor’ is not added. Coke and most soft drinks do contain alcohol. Only a thoroughly dumb man or a man who has a rabidly prejudiced in favour of these drinks, will try to deny this truth which the non-Muslim laboratories confirm. In fact, the manufacturers of the concentrates/essence used by the soft drink makers, also confirm that these concentrates contain a very high percentage of alcohol even if it is not called ‘liquor’. The alcohol-content of the flavours used to produces the drinks is anything up to 95%.

    While Sanha prides itself with its system of ‘inspection’, it is still wet behind the ears. It lacks proper expertise in this field. This is amply born out by its statement: “This was confirmed by our personal visit to a Coke Bottling Plant.” While Sanha’s amateurish inspection can ‘confirm’ that Coke does not bottle conventional liquor, it is utterly baseless for it to say that Coke does “not bottle any alcoholic beverages.” It can only venture this fallacy if it discards Islam’s meaning of ‘alcoholic beverages’. And, this it has done by accepting the western meaning of ‘alcoholic beverages’.

    We categorically claim with confidence that Coke does add alcohol as an ingredient to its soft drinks. When we had made this claim and published it in The Majlis more than 20 years ago, a Coke executive director from Johannesburg came to interview us. He was confident that he would be able to disprove our contention, get an apology, and a retraction published. During the discussion when he realised that we had cornered him, he pleaded ignorance of the alcoholic concentrates which were being added to produce the variety of flavours. He promised to investigate. He never came back to us. In fact, we told him that the Coke Co. should sue us if they can prove our claim to be false. He never came back to us because he understood that we were fully apprized of the alcoholic concentrates which are vital constituents of soft drinks. Minus the alcoholic concentrates, you have only a mixture of water and sugar. During our inspection of the P.E. Coke Plant, while everything was shown to us, the ‘dark’ room was kept locked. When we insisted to inspect it, they very reluctantly unlocked the door. All the bottles of ‘liquor’ (liquor in Islamic terminology and meaning) were stacked in the dark room. Imagine them denying awareness of the alcohol-content of the concentrates in the dark room when we pointed this out to them. So, Sanha should desist from speaking nonsense and not think that those who understand can be bamboozled by its defective visiting to the manufacturing plants. We reiterate that Coke, Sparletta and other soft drinks all are made by adding heavily laced alcohol—the concentrates—to syrup-water. Let Sanha now deny this.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible for women to wear imitation jewellery?

    All imitation jewellery besides a ring, is permissible for women. Only gold or silver rings may be worn.

    Back to top


    ·  Can any other Tasbeeh besides the usual Tasbeeh be recited in Ruku and Sajdah?

    According to the Hanafi Math-hab, it is Sunnatul Muakkadah to recite the usual Tasbeeh. It is Makrooh to recite any other Tasbeeh in Ruku and Sajdah. In fact, according to the Hambali Math-hab it is Waajib to recite the Masnoon Tasbeeh.

    Back to top


    ·  A man said to his wife: “If you cut your hair, you are divorced.” If the wife does not cut her hair herself but asks someone else to cut it, will the ruling differ?

    Even if someone else cuts her hair, Talaaq will come into effect.

    Back to top


    ·  When someone dies in our family, members of the family congregate at the home of the deceased. A lady from the community is contracted to prepare the food for us. The food is not simple. Exotic Italian food, pasta, steak, salad, chicken, etc., etc. are the dishes. It is like Eid. Cakes and refreshments are also served. The mourners and sympathisers all join in the feast. This feasting continues for a couple of days, up to the 1st weekend. What is the view of the Shariah on this type of feasting?

    This type of feasting and merrymaking on the occasion of death are most despicable and haraam. Such waste and frivolity, especially on death occasions have no place in Islam.

    These are bid’ah customs. It is not permissible to even eat this food. At most, some family members may prepare food for the bereaved inmates of the home only. Outsiders, should not join in. No one should be invited. Death is not an occasion of feasting and merrymaking.

    It is a time to reflect and understand that tomorrow it is our turn to embark on this fateful journey into Barzakh.

    THIS HARAAM CUSTOM
    About this haraam merrymaking function organized on death occasions, someone wrote:

    “The Irish have a tradition called ‘WAKE’. They organize a party after the funeral to celebrate the life of the deceased. They tell stories and anecdotes about the deceased. Then they get drunk. Our society, I am sorry to say, seems to be re-modelling itself towards this Irish tradition…...The cost of yesterday’s death-function meal was approximately R3,000.”

    Indeed, all haraam customs are adopted from different kuffaar cultures.

    Back to top


    ·  I am a layman and in need of guidance. A Maulana visits our town twice every year since the past 7 years. Over the past five years the Maulana conducted khaanqah, and also I’tikaaf of the last ten days of Ramadhaan. Programmes are tight throughout. The ladies programmes are held daily for two hours. Though we do have a radio transmitter at the Mosque and most houses have radios, the visiting Maulana does not allow switching on these transmitters. He insists that the women should travel to the Mosque where they sit in the hall and listen. These ladies travel about 10 km alone or with a driver. Is it proper to allow these ladies to travel these distances to listen to the bayaan of the Maulana?

    The conduct and attitude of this Maulana Saheb are decidedly in conflict with the Shariah, Taqwa and good morality. It is haraam for the ladies to drive and travel 10 km alone or with a ghair mahram driver. The Maulana’s insistence on the women’s emergence is in diametric conflict with the Qur’aan’s command for them to remain indoors. His attitude is extremely repugnant and fishy. Why would he impose the haraam burden on women to emerge from the sanctity of their homes, travel 10 km in the company of a ghair mahram or alone just to listen to his bayaans. The aggravating factor is that although the women can comfortably sit in the safety of their homes listening to the bayaan via the transmission system installed in the Musjid, he intransigently insists that they act in violation of the Qur’aanic prohibition to attend his bayaan. It is necessary to terminate these visits of the Maulana Saheb. Under Deeni guise, there appears to be fitnah lurking.

    Back to top


    ·  Q. Is the 10 day Ramadhaan I’tikaaf an infiraadi (individual) or an Ijtima-i (congregational) ibaadat? Most of the people need a break because the daily schedules are tight and extensive. Feeding roughly 100 people daily for 10 days —Sehri, Iftaar, Dinner after Taraaweeh and again after the night bayaan at about 11 pm. The Maulana’s host and his mureeds are compelled to participate in this khaanqah activity every year. The participants have a hypocritical stand. The majority talks negatively of this state of affairs. Please comment.

    The 10 day Ramadhaan I’tikaaf is an infiraadi ibaadat. It is not a congregational ibaadat. The gluttonous feasting, especially during the month of Ramadhaan, is vile in particular. Only beasts devour food in the manner described by you. This is indeed a ridiculous set up which the Mauana Saheb has fabricated under guise of Tasawwuf. It is haraam to impose the hardship of preparing meals for so many people, especially during Ramadhaan. The negative talk is sufficient evidence for the unlawful impositions on the womenfolk. The people who participate in this feasting are also blameworthy. It is not permissible to impose the burden of feeding so many people, so many times a day, and that too, in Ramadhaan.

    Back to top


    ·  According to Hadhrat Mufti Shafi (rahmatullah alayh), burning incense in the Musjid is a Sunnat practice which should be revived, yet The Majlis has labelled it a bid’ah. Please comment on this conflict.

    There is no conflict. When even a Sunnat which is not Muakkadah, becomes a salient feature of the Ahl-e-Bid’ah, then it becomes necessary to refrain from the Mustahab or Sunnat act. This is a well-known principle to the Ulama. Burning incense, especially on Friday night is an incumbent practice of the Ahl-e- Bid’ah. In a place where this practice is not a bid’ah, it will be appropriate to implement it.

    Back to top


    ·  If one owns more than one property which are utilized to generate income, are the values of these properties subject to Zakaat?

    There is no Zakaat on fixed property even if income is received from the properties. Zakaat is paid on the income if the cash is still in one’s possession when one’s Zakaat year ends. If the rent received from the properties have been spent, then there is no Zakaat on this depleted income. Zakaat will be incumbent on fixed property only if it was purchased with the intention of reselling it.

    Back to top


    ·  A Maulana has been employed to be the Imaam of a Musjid. After one and half years he suddenly started holding the Asaa during the Jumuah khutbah.

    Holding the asaa for the Jumuah khutbah is an incumbent characteristic of the people of Bid’ah. They consider the asaa to be Waajib, hence it is bid’ah. The Maulana Saheb must have been influenced by some miscreants to adopt the way of the Ahl-e-Bid’ah.

    Back to top


    ·  Some time ago I gave my business to my son to escape the heavy burden of debts. However, I still use funds from the business to finance some of my other projects. I intend to go for Nafl Hajj, but I was advised to rather pay the debts instead of going for Nafl Hajj. I wish to go for Hajj as I feel that I am not responsible for the debts as my son is now the owner of the business. Also, the debts are business debts not personal debts. Please advise.

    Personal or business debts are the same. The debts belong to you, not to your son even though he is working and paying. The creditors did not absolve you of the debts. Furthermore, the business still belongs to you. The gift of the shop was not executed correctly. You are still taking money from the shop for your other projects. This indicates that your son is not the true owner. If your son is unable to pay your debts, you remain liable. It is infinitely better to pay the debts. Cancel your plans for Nafl Hajj.

    Back to top


    ·  There is a piece of land opposite the Musjid. This land was on sale for more than a year. Everyone in the community was aware of this. About a month ago a Muslim of this locality purchased the land. Some members of the Musjid committee objected to him purchasing the land. They claim that from the beginning the Musjid committee was interested in this land. The committee had approached the owner of the land on numerous occasions, but due to the high price did not buy it. According to the committee the Musjid had the first right of purchase. Secondly, they claim that the purchaser was dutibound to first inform the Musjid committee of his intention to buy the land. Although the purchaser did send someone to inform the Musjid committee of his intention to buy, they did not respond at that time. Many Muslims were interested in buying the land, but the Musjid committee prevented them.

    • Was it permissible for the Musjid committee to prevent others from purchasing the land?
    • Is it correct that the Musjid has the first right of buying the land?
    • Was it binding on the purchaser to inform the Musjid committee of his intention to purchase the land?
    • Does the Musjid committee have any right of objecting to the sale?

    Haqqush Shufah (Preamptive right to purchase) relates to adjacent land, not land on the opposite side. Another requirement is the willingness and ability of the immediate neighbour to pay the price the owner of the land wants. In view of both these conditions not found, the Musjid has no preamptive right to buy the said piece of land, neither does it have any moral right because the land was put up for sale for more than a year. Everyone was aware that the land was up for sale. The Musjid committee had refused to pay the price. It was wrong and un-Islamic to prevent others from purchasing the land. It was selfish of the committee to adopt such underhand tactics to prevent others from exercising their lawful Shar’i right. If a non-Muslim had purchased the land, the committee would not have reacted in this selfish manner. Although the purchaser had informed the Musjid committee, he was not under legal obligation of the Shariah to inform them. The permission of the committee was not a requisite for the purchase of the land. The committee has no right of objecting to the purchase.

    Back to top


    ·  I request that The Majlis research and publish its findings on the computer games in which the youth indulge in today. The evil, satanic and immoral sexual content is extremely explicit.

    What is there to research in zina—adultery and fornication? Every Muslim who indulges in fornication is fully aware that it is not permissible to even look at a ghair mahram woman. There cannot be a Muslim on earth who happens to be spiritually rotting in these filthy, noxious and stercoraceous computer ‘games’ who does not know that this moral muck and filth are haraam. Any person who recites the Kalimah and indulges in this type of najaasat with the idea that it is permissible, is in fact not a Muslim. If he/she was born a Muslim, he/she leaves the fold of Islam the moment he/she believes that this type of zina is lawful.

    Furthermore, the type of research you have suggested entails us sitting in front of the computer ruining our eyes, mind and heart watching the very filth which you are condemning. This issue does not require any research. It requires Amr Bil Ma’roof Nahy anil Munkar. The Ulama, Imaams and parents have to constantly admonish their flocks on this evil. There is a tremendous lack of parental ta’leem and tarbiyat, as well as an almost total abdication of the Waajib obligation of Prohibiting evil by the Ulama in this age.

    Back to top


    ·  If a wife works and earns, does it still remain the obligation of the husband to see to her nafqah (household expenses)?

    There are several angles to this question. If the woman is compelled by the husband to work and earn, then he is still responsible for her maintenance. If she works outside the home with his consent, then both are guilty of major sins. In this case, he is not obliged to pay nafqah. If she is forced by her husband to work, whether it is a home-based work to earn, or whether she has to work outside the home, then it remains Waajib on her husband to fully maintain her. In all cases, her earnings are her own property over which her husband has no right.

    Back to top


    ·  Have you approved the financial schemes of Westbank? Some Ulama say that the Mujlisul Ulama has sanctioned it.

    The matter is still in the discussion stage. We have not as yet sanctioned any product offered by Westbank. There are still some issues which need attention by Westbank. Hopefully, these will be resolved. But at this stage there are still some clauses which render Westbank’s Ijaarah (Leasing) Agreement invalid in the Shariah. As far as the other schemes presented by FNB-Westbank are concerned, the details have just been made available to us. We are busy studying these.

    Back to top


    ·  A husband said to his wife in anger: “We are already half divorced.” Is this a valid Talaaq?

    One Talaaq Raj’i (Revocable Divorce) came into effect by this statement.

    Back to top


    ·  In most Musjids around Dewsbury, England, the Committees are charging membership fees, as if to say that the Musjid is some kind of club. Is this permissible?

    Membership fees are haraam. Membership fee is an imposition which comes under the purview of Riba. It is haraam interest. It is not permissible to charge membership fees for being members of any organisation, whether Musjid, Madrasah or any other kind of association. Membership fees are particularly abominable when related to a Musjid.

    Back to top


    ·  Is copyright permissible in Islam? If not, why?

    Copyright, patent right, and the like are haraam. In past issues of The Majlis we had explained this prohibition more than once. We are presently printing a book on this topic. As soon as the book is ready, we shall, Insha’Allah, announce it in The Majlis.

    Copyrights and the Shariah @ http://books.themajlis.net/node/331
    read also http://www.themajlis.net/Article22.html

    Back to top


    ·  I have heard some people saying that if a plant such as a rose plant is put on the grave, the athaab of Allah does not come. Also, if some berries are planted and the birds come and eat, they recite Tasbeeh for the mayyit. Is this correct?

    Whatever is not substantiated by the Qur’aan and Sunnah is conjecture no matter how logical and beneficial it may appear. No one can claim with certitude that Athaab is lifted if wild birds eat from the berries planted on a grave or by the Tasbeeh of the flower. Placing flowers on the grave is not permissible because this is a custom of non-Muslims, and it was never ever done by Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam), the Sahaabah, the Taabieen and Tabe-Taabieen. If there was merit in this practice, Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) would have encouraged it. What could be said in this regard is that on only one occasion in his entire lifetime did Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) split a twig in two and placed one half on each of the two graves when it was revealed to him that the inmates were undergoing severe punishment. When placing the twigs, Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) expressed the hope that the punishment may be lightened as long as the twigs remained fresh and recited Tasbeeh. He did not categorically claim that the punishment will be terminated nor did he ever repeat this act on any other grave, nor did the Sahaabah and the Salf-e-Saaliheen thereafter adopt this as a Sunnat practice. It was never implemented. From this we understand that we should not seek to surpass Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) and the Sahaabah in matters of the Deen. There is no more effective method for benefiting the mayyit (deceased) than Dua-e-Maghfirat and rendering acts of
    virtue on his/her behalf.

    Back to top


    ·  Are all Shiah sects non-Muslim due to their outrageous beliefs?

    Some centuries ago there were some Shiah sects who were Muslims despite their deviation. They did not subscribe to the kufr beliefs which Shi’ism in general propagates. We are not aware if members of such sects still exist or not. But, Shi’ism as we see it today is kufr.

    Back to top


    ·  I have been told that the Salafis reject the four Math-habs. Is this true?

    Yes, it is true. They have a rabid aversion for the Four Math-habs of the Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jama’ah.

    Back to top


    ·  In a Musjid a musalli going out, passes about 3 metres in front of someone performing Salaat. Does his Salaat break?

    No, his Salaat does not break. Passing in front of musallis should be avoided.

    Back to top


    ·  A young Maulana from Jalalabad propagates that it is not Sunnat to engage in the congregational dua after Fardh Salaat. His attitude has eroded the significance of this dua, hence many musallis who used to participate in the Ijtimaa’i Dua no longer do so. What is the status of this Dua after Fardh Salaat?

    Making Dua after Fardh Salaat is Sunnat. It is a very Maqbool time according to the Ahadith. The Ijtima’i Dua has always been the practice of the Akaabir Ulama and the Auliya. The young Maulana hailing from Jalalabad should have initiated his reckless propaganda while he was studying at Jalalabad. He should have opposed his Asaatizah on this issue. Then he should have gone to Daarul Uloom Deoband which is just an hour away, and convince all the Ulama there of their error in participating in the Ijtima’i Dua. Then he should have journeyed to Saharanpur, less than an hour’s bus ride, and tackled all the senior Ulama over there by engaging them in debate on this practice. What has constrained this inexperienced youngster to criticize a practice which the
    Ulama-e-Haqq—all the Akaabireen of Deoband— have always adhered to? These Akaabireen were on the forefront in the fight against Bid’ah and Baatil. All of them were branded as kaafir by the Qabar Pujari Bid’ati Jamaat for their resolute stand against bid’ah. Now, the new kind of molvi comes to wag his tongue against the Sunnat practice of the Akaabireen. What they considered Sunnat is Sunnat. The inexperienced follower of intemperate opinion enslaved to the wildly fluctuating promptings of the nafs should understand that true hidaayat lies in subordination of our opinion to the established and unanimous decrees, verdicts, practices and proclamations of the Akaabireen whose knowledge, piety and practices are all rooted in the Qur’aan and Sunnah and passed on to them from the Salf-e-Saaliheen. It never was the practice and style of our Akaabireen to dig out ibaadat practices from the kutub. They acquired their ibaaadaat from above—from seniors by way of Isnaad—a Chain of Authority linking to the Sahaabah.

    Back to top


    ·  I read in an Islamic newsletter that the wall of Dhul-Qarnayn is located in a place called Durbend in the former Soviet Union. Is this true?

    No one knows the location of the Barrier erected by Dhul-Qarnayn (rahmatullah alayh). What you have read is pure conjecture. There is no validity for this.

    Back to top


    ·  I bought some clothes and received 10% discount. However, I returned the clothes for a refund. There was no defect in the goods. I was given a refund of the actual price. I told them to deduct the 10% which they had given me, but they insisted on giving me the full price. In other words, I made a 10% profit. Is it proper for me to accept and use this money?

    After you had paid for the goods, you became the owner. When you returned the clothes which were not defective, you were in actual fact selling your own property. At that juncture you were the seller and the shop accepting the clothes was the buyer. It is permissible to negotiate a new price. The profit of 10% which you made is therefore halaal. However, there remains a lingering doubt. If the shop is a supermarket, hypermarket or a big wholesaler and the refund was made arbitrarily by the cashier, then it is possible that the cashier used his/her discretion to refund to you a sum more than what you had actually paid, and was not acting according to company policy or practice. If this is so, then while the sale is still lawful, it enters into the Mushtbahah (Doubtful) category. It is, therefore, advisable that you give the 10% extra to charity.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to perform Salaat with Tayammum on a plane?

    As long as water is available on the plane and you are able to make wudhu, Salaat with Tayammum will not be valid. Making wudhu on the plane, although inconvenient, can be done. All those who perform Salaat on planes, perform with wudhu. Wearing Khuffain makes Wudhu easier.

    Back to top


    ·  Please explain the difference between TV and Computer pictures.

    There is no difference whatsoever regarding the prohibition of pictures of animate objects whether the pictures are made by the TV method or the computer method, the digital camera, or any other method existing and still to be invented. All pictures of animate objects regardless of the method and instruments of production are haraam.

    Back to top


    ·  I have an uncle who works for an insurance company. If he invites us or gives us food as a gift, is it permissible to eat his food and accept his gifts?

    Since his earnings are haraam, his gifts and food are likewise haraam. It is neither permissible to accept his gifts nor to consume his food. His invitation should be declined. Explain to him in a humble and nice manner the
    reason for declining. In this way you will be doing him a favour.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to consume processed food manufactured in Islamic countries if the products contain doubtful additives?

    There are no Islamic countries existing today. Haraam ingredients are used in all Muslim countries in the same way these are used in non-Muslim countries. It is necessary to abstain from processed food containing these doubtful additives, especially E-numbers even if made in Muslim countries.

    Back to top


    ·  How should a carpet soiled with urine be purified?

    In the same way as najis (impure—napaak) garments are cleansed by washing and squeezing. To facilitate purification of the carpet, a vacuum cleaner with water could also be used. Fresh water should be flushed onto the soiled area and sucked out with the machine. The process should be repeated several times until one feels confident that all impurity has been eliminated. If a machine is not available, the carpet will simply have to be removed, washed and placed in the sun to dry. It does not matter how expensive the carpet may be. The Deen is priceless and the Ahkaam of the Shariah are invaluable. If the carpet is too big and has been fitted wall to wall, then the affected part has to be cut and removed. It may later be sewn again.

    Back to top


    ·  While travelling in a car, during an argument with my wife, I lost my temper and uttered: “Talaaq, Talaaq, Talaaq, and again Talaaq, Talaaq, Talaaq.” What is our marital status? A sheikh from an Islamic institute says that Talaaq did not take place.

    The sheikh is a deviate. Only deviates issue such corrupt ‘fatwas’. Your marriage had ended the moment you had uttered the Talaaqs. Three Talaaqs finally and irrevocably terminate the Nikah.

    Back to top


    ·  Are nazams with thikr in the background permissible?

    Such nazams (songs) and using thikr for such nafsaani entertainment are haraam. The purpose of thikr is not entertainment. Thikr is the highest act of ibaadat for which Allah Ta’ala has created us. It is despicable to abuse Allah’s Name in this contemptible nafsaani manner. Shaitaan is adept in the art of deceiving people under Deeni and ‘ibaadat’ guises.

    Back to top


    ·  Are Raatibul Gadat gatherings permissible? They get together reciting various
    Surahs aloud in chorus.

    These are bid’ah gatherings. It is not permissible to participate.

    Back to top


    ·  Please state the Shariah’s ruling on ‘big walk’ functions conducted for charity and other purposes. Thousands of Muslims gather to participate in a 10 km walk for charity. Sheikhs and Imaams, men, women and children all participate. Does Islam allow this kind of behaviour?

    Any ordinary Muslim with healthy Imaan can understand the evil of such a ‘big walk’ stupid practices. One need not be an Aalim to understand the many wrongs concomitant to this kuffaar practice. One only needs Imaan and eyes, not even spiritual eyes. Only physical eyes and a mind unpolluted with the evils of western life are the requirements for understanding the Shariah’s revulsion and prohibition of this type of haraam practice. The participation of shiekhs and imaams is a sign of the impending Hour which Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) predicted. In one Hadith it is said:

    “Verily, I fear for my Ummah the deviated imaams who will mislead (my Ummah).”

    We are witnessing this event being enacted by the deviated so-called sheikhs and imaams. They are morally deranged and corrupted, hence they take the masses along with them into the bowels of the eternal Fire of Jahannum. About these sheikhs and imaams who mislead their ignorant flocks, Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) said:

    “Soon will there be in my Ummah such people in whom these lusts (of the nafs) will permeate, just as a rabid dog has afflicted the one whom it has bitten. Not a vein or a joint of (the bitten person) will remain in which the disease has not embedded itself.”

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to buy and sell cell phones with built-in cameras?

    A cell phone even with a built-in camera is an item of valid use. The sin of misuse is on the user. It is permissible to buy and sell such cell phones just as it is permissible to buy and sell guns and knives. Those who wrongly use these instruments are responsible for the sins.

    Back to top


    ·  I have been told that Ishraaq and Dhuhaa (Chaasht) are one and the same Salaat.
    Is this correct?

    According to the Hanafi Math-hab, these are two separate Salaats.

    Back to top


    ·  How is it to join the Asr Jamaat which Shaafis perform during a time which is still Zuhr for Hanafis?

    Hanafis should not perform Asr Salaat when it is still Zuhr time according to their Math-hab. They should not join the Jamaat performing Asr during the Hanafi Zuhr time.

    Back to top


    ·  What is the Sunnat method of applying oil to the hair and beard?

    We have not come across any narration on this. Perhaps some other Ulama have. Anyhow, in terms of principles, pour oil on the right hand and apply first to the right side, then to the left side.

    Back to top


    ·  There is a Muslim club called Crescent Running Club. Among its activities are mixing of sexes. Wives mix with men who are not their husbands, yet some of them perform their Namaaz. Is there any scope in Islam for such a club?

    There is no need to answer this question. Every ignorant Muslim is aware of the evil of zina. Intermingling is the stage set by shaitaan for indulgence in zina. The reason for mentioning this question here is to remind Muslims that participation in a club of this nature is not any different from the perpetration of zina.

    Back to top


    ·  What are the Shariah’s requirements regarding the funeral rites for a stillborn
    child?

    The stillborn child will be bathed without observing the Masnoon ghusl method if the foetus is not fully developed, but buried in the normal Masnoon way. If the stillborn is a fully developed child, Masnoon ghusl will be given, but Janaazah Salaat will not be performed.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to erect four walls around the grave without plastering over
    the grave?

    The erection of such walls or any other structure on or over or around the grave is haraam.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it Sunnat to make dua after walking 70 steps from the grave, after having buried the mayyit?

    This is a bid’ah practice. It is not permissible.

    Back to top


    ·  The mother of a deceased child is a Muslim and the father a non-Muslim. How
    should the child be buried—as a Muslim or non-Muslim?

    In all cases where one parent is a Muslim, the child will be regarded as a Muslim and buried as such.

    Back to top


    ·  When the muath-thin is absent, and present in the Musjid are only the Imaam and
    one musalli who is beardless, wears his trousers below his ankles, does not wear a topi and has renounced the Hanafi Mathhab which he used to follow, who should recite the Athaan and the Iqaamah?

    The Imaam should recite both the Athaan and the Iqaamah. The faasiq should not be allowed the honour of calling the Athaan and the Iqaamah. Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) said: “When a faasiq is honoured, the Arsh of Allah shudders.”

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to invest in the Unit Trust schemes which Muslim banks offer?

    It is not permissible. The deals offered by the Muslim-owned banks are not free from riba.

    [Please visit http://books.themajlis.net/node/297 ]

    Back to top


    ·  I asked a friend to pay my Zakaat. He did so with his own money. After he paid
    my Zakaat, I forwarded the money to him. Is my Zakaat validly discharged?

    Yes, your Zakaat is validly paid.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to buy and deal in shares on the stock exchange?

    It is not permissible to deal in these riba and baatil ‘shares’.

    [Please visit http://books.themajlis.net/node/297 and http://themajlis.net/Article147.html ]

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible to participate in the Oasis Crescent Equity Fund and in Al-Baraka Equity Fund?

    It is not permissible.

    Back to top


    ·  Is bovine gelatine halaal?

    Bovine gelatine and all animal gelatine are haraam. Products containing animal gelatine are haraam.

    Back to top


    ·  Is it permissible for a Muslim to sponsor a golf tournament?

    Such sponsorship is not permissible. It is sinful to support a haraam act in any way.

    Back to top


    ·  Last year during the Taraaweeh Salaat announcements were made in our Musaajid regarding Sajdah Tilaawat in the 23rd Juz. Since the Sajdah at this juncture is a Sajdah Shukr for Shaafis, they were advised to remain standing while Hanafis make the Sajdah which is Waajib for them. Please comment on this issue.

    According to the Shaafi Math-hab, the Sajdah in Surah Swaad in the 23rd Juz, is Sajdah Shukr. It is not permissible for Shaafis to make Sajdah of Shukr in Salaat. If they do make such a Sajdah, their Salaat becomes baatil. In view of this categorical ruling of the Shaafi Math-hab, Shaafis have to remain standing
    while the Hanafis make the Sajdah.

    Back to top


    ·  Why is it that most Muslim businessmen pay their staff very poorly? They would rather donate large amounts to Tsunami victims, Bangladesh, Palestine, Iraq, Khanqas, etc. But they seem to think that paying their staff properly is not meritorious. Their wives get the best of everything while we cannot afford to buy a good set of clothes for our wives. They go out in jamaat, Hajj and Umrah, and they waste so much money on their children. They buy cars for their children. Please comment on this attitude of the businessmen.

    It appears from your complaints, impatience (lack of Sabr), and deficiency in the belief of Allah’s Providence (Razzaaqiyat) that you are more in need of Naseehat than the businessmen who exploit their workers. Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) instructed that you should focus on those who have less than you. Then, you will recognize the abundance of bounties Allah Ta’ala has favoured you with. You will then express shukr (gratitude) for the Rizq Allah Ta’ala has decreed for you. If you focus on those who have more than you, hasad (envy) will develop in you.

    You will then complain as you are doing now, and be ungrateful for the ni’maat which Allah Ta’ala has bestowed to you. Businessmen and their workers all have their own quota and variety of evils and sins in which they indulge.

    If businessmen are exploiting their workers, it is undoubtedly un-Islamic and wrong. But your complaints, your ingratitude to Allah Ta’ala, and your dissatisfaction with your divinely decreed measure of Rizq will not solve the problem of employer-exploitation.

    Don’t worry about the wives and children of your employer. Don’t react with hasad (jealousy) when they spend on themselves and make charitable contributions. Far from solving your problems, you only multiply and worsen them. Impatience and jealousy on account of the possessions of others and malice for those who have more than you and who refuse to give to you, whether justly or unjustly, are in fact complaints directed against the apportioning
    of Rizq by Allah Ta’ala. Allah Ta’ala has created people in different classes—the rich, the poor, the middle class, the suffering and the prosperous.

    Leave the wrongdoers and oppressors to Allah Ta’ala while you express your shukr and satisfaction to Him. Make sincere dua for betterment of your lot.

    Back to top


    ·  A woman wanted to cut her hair. Her husband said: ‘If you cut your hair, you are divorced.’ What if she, herself, does not cut her hair, but asks someone else to cut it? Will Talaaq come into effect?

    Yes, one Talaaq-e-Raj’i comes into effect even if she asks someone else to cut her hair.

    Back to top




    "Copyrights - Restraining The Word of Allah"
    The site is best viewed at 1024X768 resolution